Agents vs Chatbots: The Autonomy Spectrum

It is common to hear the terms "AI Agent" and "AI Chatbot" used interchangeably. However, to an engineer, they are fundamentally different architectures. The difference lies in Agency—the ability to plan and act without being spoon-fed every instruction.

1. The Reactive Chatbot

A chatbot is primarily Reactive. It takes an input, processes it, and provides an output. Even if it uses a tool (like searching Google), it usually does so in a single, linear step.

graph LR
    User[User Message] --> LLM[Chatbot LLM]
    LLM --> Tool[One-off Tool Use]
    Tool --> Result[Final Answer]

---

2. The Proactive Agent

An agent is Proactive. Given a complex goal ("Write a report on Nvidia's last 3 earnings calls"), an agent realizes it cannot do this in one step. It must:

1. Plan: Break the goal into sub-goals.
2. Act: Search for the first call, take notes, search for the second, etc.
3. Refine: If it fails to find a piece of data, it tries a different search term.
4. Finalize: Only after several loops does it return the result.

graph TD
    Goal[User Goal] --> Loop{Loop Action}
    Loop --> ToolA[Search Tool]
    ToolA --> ResultA[Data Found]
    ResultA --> Loop
    Loop --> ToolB[Math Tool]
    ToolB --> ResultB[Calculation done]
    ResultB --> Loop
    Loop --> Done[Final Goal Reached]

---

3. Key Differences

Feature	Chatbot	Agent
Workflow	Linear (In -> Out)	Iterative (Loop)
Control	User-led	Goal-led
Tool Use	Single/Predefined	Multi-step/Dynamic
Failure Handling	Returns an error / hallucination	Tries a different approach
Example	"Summarize this PDF"	"Improve this codebase to use Python 3.12"

---

4. Code Comparison: The "Research" Task

The Chatbot Way (Linear)

def chatbot(query):
    # Chatbot just asks the model to respond
    return llm.call("Please search for X and tell me what you find.")

The Agent Way (Iterative)

class ResearchAgent:
    def solve(self, goal):
        completed = False
        while not completed:
            # 1. Ask model for the NEXT step
            thought = llm.call(f"Goal: {goal}. What is the next logical step?")
            
            # 2. Execute that specific step
            result = self.execute_step(thought)
            
            # 3. Check if we are finished
            if "FINAL_ANSWER" in result:
                completed = True
        return result

---

5. The "Agency" Test

If you can walk away from your computer for 5 minutes and the AI is still "thinking" or "working" through a sequence of tasks, you are dealing with an Agent. If it waits for you to say "Now do this" after every step, it's a Chatbot.

---

Key Takeaways

• Chatbots are linear and reactive.
• Agents are iterative and goal-oriented.
• The transition to an agent requires a Control Loop that the LLM manages.
• Agency is a spectrum: some systems are "more agentic" than others depending on how many steps they can handle autonomously.