Moving to the Cloud: Exploring Migration Patterns - The "Lift and Shift" Approach

Welcome back to Module 19: Real-World Scenarios and Use Cases! In the previous lesson, we looked at typical business use cases for AWS services. Now, we'll delve into the practical process of how organizations move their existing applications and IT infrastructure to the AWS Cloud. This process is known as cloud migration, and there are several common migration patterns. For the AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner exam, understanding these patterns, especially the widely used "Lift and Shift" approach, is crucial for grasping cloud adoption strategies.

This lesson will extensively cover cloud migration patterns, focusing on the "Lift and Shift" approach. We'll explain what lift and shift is, its compelling benefits (such as speed and minimal changes), its inherent drawbacks, and when it's an appropriate strategy for rapid cloud adoption. We'll also briefly mention other common migration strategies like re-platforming and re-factoring, providing a comprehensive overview of how businesses transition to the cloud. We'll include a Mermaid diagram illustrating the lift and shift migration process.

1. What is Cloud Migration?

Cloud migration is the process of moving digital assets—applications, data, IT workloads—from an on-premises data center to the cloud, or from one cloud environment to another. It's a strategic decision driven by the desire to leverage the benefits of cloud computing, such as cost savings, scalability, agility, and enhanced global reach.

AWS has identified several common cloud migration strategies, often referred to as the "6 Rs" of migration:

1. Rehosting (Lift and Shift)
2. Replatforming (Lift, Tinker, and Shift)
3. Refactoring/Re-architecting
4. Repurchasing
5. Retain
6. Retire

For the Cloud Practitioner exam, the "Lift and Shift" (Rehosting) strategy is particularly important due to its prevalence as an initial migration step.

2. Deep Dive: Rehosting (Lift and Shift)

"Lift and Shift", formally known as Rehosting, is a cloud migration strategy where you move an application and its associated data to the cloud with minimal or no changes. You literally "lift" the application from its current environment (on-premises) and "shift" it to an IaaS cloud platform (like Amazon EC2).

How Lift and Shift Works:

1. Assess: Identify the application and its dependencies.
2. Rehost: Migrate virtual machines (VMs) and their configurations directly to Amazon EC2 instances. This often involves converting on-premises VM formats (e.g., VMware vSphere, Microsoft Hyper-V) into AMIs that can run on EC2.
3. Data Migration: Move associated data from on-premises storage to AWS storage services (e.g., Amazon EBS for attached volumes, Amazon S3 for file shares, AWS Database Migration Service for databases).
4. Connect: Re-establish network connectivity, often using VPN or AWS Direct Connect to connect the AWS environment to the original on-premises network.

Example: Migrating an On-Premises Web Server to EC2

If you have an on-premises web server running on a VM, in a lift and shift scenario, you would:

• Create an AMI (Amazon Machine Image) from your on-premises VM or use a tool like AWS Application Migration Service (AWS MGN) to automate the replication of your server to AWS as an EC2 instance.
• Launch an EC2 instance using this AMI.
• Attach relevant EBS volumes (migrated data).
• Configure network connectivity (Security Groups, route tables).

The application stack (OS, application code, middleware) remains largely unchanged.

3. Benefits of Lift and Shift

• Speed of Migration: It's often the fastest way to get applications into the cloud, especially for a large number of applications.
• Lower Initial Cost: Less engineering effort required compared to re-architecting, resulting in lower upfront migration costs.
• Minimal Application Changes: Because the application code is not changed, there's less risk of introducing new bugs or compatibility issues.
• Familiarity: IT teams can leverage their existing operational skills (e.g., managing Windows or Linux servers) on EC2 instances.
• Stepping Stone: Serves as a useful first step to gain cloud experience. Once in AWS, applications can be optimized or re-platformed later.

4. Drawbacks and Considerations of Lift and Shift

While attractive for its speed, lift and shift has limitations:

• Suboptimal Cost Optimization: The application may not fully leverage cloud-native features (like serverless or managed databases) which could offer greater cost savings. You might end up over-provisioning or paying for unused capacity, similar to on-premises.
• Limited Cloud Benefits: May not fully realize the agility, elasticity, or performance benefits of the cloud without further optimization.
• Technical Debt Ported: Existing technical debt or inefficiencies in the application are simply moved to the cloud.
• Operational Overhead: You still manage the operating system and application layer (IaaS model), requiring ongoing patching and maintenance.

5. When is Lift and Shift an Appropriate Strategy?

Lift and Shift is particularly well-suited for specific scenarios:

• Rapid Cloud Adoption: When an organization needs to quickly exit a data center or achieve a certain percentage of cloud adoption within a tight deadline.
• Legacy Applications: For applications that are difficult or too expensive to re-architect (e.g., very old, complex codebases, vendor applications with strict requirements).
• Proof of Concept: As an initial migration to demonstrate the feasibility of moving to the cloud.
• Hybrid Cloud Strategy: To move some workloads to AWS while maintaining tight integration with on-premises systems.
• Applications with Stable Demand: If an application has consistent and predictable resource requirements, lift and shift can be viable.

6. Other Migration Strategies (Brief Overview)

While lift and shift is popular, other strategies often yield greater long-term benefits:

• Replatforming (Lift, Tinker, and Shift): Moving to the cloud and making a few cloud-native optimizations to achieve some benefits.
  • Example: Moving an on-premises database to Amazon RDS (a managed service) instead of just running it on an EC2 instance.
• Refactoring/Re-architecting: Redesigning and rewriting portions of an application to fully leverage cloud-native capabilities (e.g., microservices, serverless functions, cloud-native databases). This offers the greatest benefits but is the most time-consuming and expensive.
  • Example: Converting a monolithic application to a microservices architecture using AWS Lambda and Amazon DynamoDB.
• Repurchasing (Drop and Shop): Replacing an existing application with a new cloud-native SaaS product.
  • Example: Migrating from an on-premises CRM to Salesforce.
• Retain: Keeping certain applications on-premises due to compliance, legacy integration, or strategic reasons (often part of a hybrid cloud strategy).
• Retire: Decommissioning applications that are no longer needed.

Exam Tip: Be able to distinguish between these migration strategies, especially the "6 Rs." Lift and Shift is about moving as-is. Replatforming makes some cloud-native changes. Refactoring makes significant cloud-native changes.

7. Visualizing the Lift and Shift Migration Process

graph TD
    A[On-Premises Application] --> B{AWS Application Migration Service AWS MGN}
    B --> C[Replicate Server to AWS]
    C --> D[Launch EC2 Instance from Replicated Data]
    D --> E[Attach EBS Volumes Migrated Data]
    E --> F[Configure Network VPC, Security Groups]
    F --> G[Application Running on AWS IaaS]

    style A fill:#FFD700,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style B fill:#ADD8E6,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style C fill:#90EE90,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style D fill:#FFB6C1,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style E fill:#DAF7A6,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style F fill:#ADD8E6,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
    style G fill:#90EE90,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px,color:#000

This diagram simplifies the lift and shift process, showing the replication of an on-premises server to an EC2 instance in AWS.

8. Practical Example: Using AWS Application Migration Service (AWS MGN) (Conceptual)

AWS Application Migration Service (AWS MGN) is the primary service for rehosting (lift and shift) physical servers, virtual machines, and cloud instances to AWS. It automates the migration of your servers from physical infrastructure, VMware vSphere, Microsoft Hyper-V, or other clouds to AWS.

# Conceptual steps for using AWS MGN:

# 1. Install the AWS Replication Agent on your source servers (on-premises VMs).
#    (This is an agent you download and run on the server to be migrated.)

# 2. Configure AWS MGN in the AWS Management Console:
#    - Set up replication settings.
#    - Identify source servers.
#    - Launch test instances in AWS to verify migration.
#    - Perform cutover to launch target EC2 instances.

# While direct CLI commands for a full MGN workflow are complex and multi-step,
# you can interact with MGN via CLI for specific tasks, e.g., listing source servers:

aws mgn describe-source-servers \
    --query 'items[].{SourceServerID:sourceServerID,InstanceState:lifeCycle.state,OS:os.fullString}' \
    --output table

Explanation:

• aws mgn describe-source-servers: Lists information about the source servers that have the AWS Replication Agent installed and are being managed by AWS MGN.
• --query 'items[].{...}' --output table: Formats the output to show the Source Server ID, its lifecycle state, and OS details in a readable table.

This command demonstrates a way to monitor the status of your lift and shift migrations through AWS MGN, highlighting the tool's role in facilitating this migration pattern.

Conclusion: A Strategic Entry to the Cloud

The "Lift and Shift" (Rehosting) cloud migration pattern offers a rapid and relatively low-cost entry point to the AWS Cloud, particularly for organizations looking to quickly exit data centers or migrate legacy applications with minimal changes. While it may not immediately unlock all the cloud's benefits, it serves as a valuable first step, allowing organizations to gain cloud experience and optimize their workloads once they are natively running on AWS. For the AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner exam, understanding lift and shift's characteristics, its benefits and drawbacks, and when it's an appropriate strategy is crucial for grasping fundamental cloud adoption strategies.

---

Knowledge Check